Section 5 of 9 · Reading a 990

Red Flags and What They Mean

The figures that should make you look twice, and the ones that shouldn't.

Most of what looks alarming on a Form 990 has an innocent explanation, and most genuine problems are quiet rather than dramatic. A red flag isn’t a verdict — it’s a question you haven’t answered yet. Here are the ones worth raising, and what each actually means before you jump to a conclusion.

Chronic deficits and shrinking net assets.

One down year is noise. Several in a row, with net assets sliding each time, is an organization spending its cushion to stay open. That’s the most important warning the financials carry, because it’s about survival rather than efficiency. The question to ask is which kind it is: a deliberate draw-down, where a board chooses to spend reserves on purpose, or a slow bleed nobody has moved to stop. The 990 shows you the pattern; only context tells you which one you’re looking at.

Insider transactions.

Schedule L is where the 990 discloses dealings between the organization and its own people — loans to or from officers, business done with a board member’s company, assistance to insiders. None of this is automatically improper; small organizations in particular do legitimate business with people connected to the board. But every one of these is worth understanding, because this is where conflicts of interest live if they live anywhere. When you see a Schedule L entry, the question is simply whether the transaction was at arm’s length.

Compensation out of proportion.

The number that matters isn’t the size of a salary — it’s the salary relative to the organization’s size, complexity, and what comparable groups pay. A $400K chief executive at a $90M institution may be entirely reasonable; the same figure at a $2M organization is a question worth asking. Watch, too, for compensation that spikes sharply year over year with no matching growth in the organization. Proportion is the test, never the dollar figure on its own.

The fundraiser keeps most of the money.

When an organization hires outside professional fundraisers, Schedule G shows how much was raised and how much the firm kept. Sometimes the split is ugly: the firm retains half of every dollar or more, and only a thin slice reaches the mission. This is legal and more common than donors imagine, but it’s a real efficiency and ethics question. If most of what’s raised never reaches the cause, that’s worth knowing before you give to — or partner with — the organization.

Big unexplained swings.

A revenue, expense, or asset figure that jumps or drops sharply from one year to the next isn’t a problem by itself — a capital campaign, a major bequest, or a building sale all do that. The flag is a large swing with no explanation attached. Schedule O is where the organization gets to narrate the unusual; when something moved hard and the narrative is silent, that silence is the signal worth following.

Governance gaps.

Part VI asks a series of yes/no questions about how the organization governs itself: independent board majority, conflict-of-interest policy, whistleblower policy, document-retention rules. None are required by law, and a single “no” is not a scandal. But a cluster of “no” answers tells you the organization runs loose — and loose governance is where larger problems tend to begin. Read Part VI as a hygiene check, not a charge sheet.

Tangled related organizations.

Schedule R lists affiliated entities — related nonprofits, controlled taxable subsidiaries, partnerships. Complexity isn’t wrongdoing; large organizations have legitimate reasons for multi-entity structures. But money moving among related organizations can also obscure where it ultimately goes, and a simple-looking charity sitting inside a web of affiliates is worth tracing before you draw conclusions from its 990 alone.

The throughline.

None of these is a conviction. Each is a prompt to look closer and ask one specific question — usually answered by context, by the schedules, or by the organization itself. Reading for red flags isn’t about catching wrongdoing; it’s about knowing what you don’t yet understand. Most flags resolve the moment you have the rest of the story, which is why 990 Schedules Explained is the natural next stop, and why Financial Health Signals is worth rereading once you know what you’re looking for.

>