Mission-Driven Giving at Work: What Faith-Based Campaigns Can Teach the Philanthropy Sector

Stone stairway ascending through clouds toward bright sunlight

Where mission is hollow, money vanishes. But when purpose rings true, donors rise. Faith-based campaigns show how conviction forges loyalty stronger than any strategy.

Reading Time: 3 minutes

Not all philanthropic efforts take the same shape. While every nonprofit organization exists to advance a mission or provide a public benefit rather than generate profit, the ways they approach fundraising can vary widely.

Faith-based fundraising campaigns offer valuable insights to the rest of the philanthropy sector. Rooted in centuries of practice, these campaigns demonstrate how deeply aligning fundraising with mission, values, and community can inspire generosity. Their lessons extend well beyond faith-based contexts and can strengthen fundraising strategies across the philanthropic sector.

A key term in faith-based fundraising is stewardship, which is the idea of offering your time, talent, and treasure in support of a mission or goal. Being good stewards of the money granted to us by God is a foundation of strong faith-based fundraising.

What is Mission-Driven Giving?

Mission-driven giving is the practice of donors supporting an organization because they are deeply motivated by the organization’s mission or purpose. A donor feels the values and mission of an organization align with their core values as a person.

Why is it Important to Consider Mission-Driven Giving?

As the historic transfer of wealth (see also window of opportunity) continues in the United States, Millennials and Gen Z will become the main donors for many organizations. Mission-driven giving is a key to reaching these younger generations.

Fidelity Charitable found that Millennials view philanthropy quite differently from others:

  • Nearly 75% of Millennials view themselves as philanthropists, compared to 48% of Gen X and only 35% of Baby Boomers.
  • Millennial donors are fueled by social change being core to how they live their lives.
  • Younger donors don’t want to donate and then sit back. They see a donation as an investment in a solution and have an increased focus on seeing the effectiveness of their support demonstrated.

Faith-Based Blueprint: Building Community and Purpose

Faith-based campaigns have a unique opportunity to rely on a donor base that is present and invested in the community itself. Whether it is a church, religious school, or a nonprofit founded in a religion, its donors are not just supporters but faithfully invested in the fundraising effort.

Key Lessons From Faith-Based Giving Initiatives

  1. Powerful storytelling communicates your mission.

    Share authentic stories of those whose lives have been impacted by your organization’s work. Those who have benefitted from the financial gifts are the best witnesses of why you do what you do. Move beyond transactional appeals and focus on narratives that highlight real impact.

  2. Focus on values-based messaging.

    Faith-based organizations often frame the idea of giving within the context of a broader spiritual message, leaning into the idea of stewardship as a call to share generously with others. In the wider philanthropic world, values-based messaging is impactful when framed within the context of doing good for others with your organization. The principle that “it is in giving that we receive” resonates beyond religious settings.

  3. Inspire consistent giving.

    Ritual and giving are readily integrated in faith-based organizations. Many churches include giving as part of worship and prayer, which creates a rhythm and habit of giving. Weaving giving opportunities into the regular and normal events of any organization can emulate this rhythm of action and giving, making generosity a consistent and expected part of community life.

  4. Be transparent.

    Trust and transparency are core to most faith-based campaigns, where donors expect accountability as part of the values structure. Any organization can strengthen its case for support by making these values central, ensuring donors feel confident that their gifts are used with integrity.

  5. Leaders lead.

    By modeling generosity themselves, pastors and church leaders can fully participate by making a sacrificial gift to a campaign first in the community. This visible participation builds credibility and makes a campaign more compelling to the rest of the community.

  6. Aim for high participation.

    Nothing can sink a campaign faster than major donors feeling like they are the only ones participating. Inviting full participation from the community allows donors to feel they are part of something larger than themselves. High participation often leads to a tighter community bond even after the campaign is done. It is not about equal giving but equal sacrifice.

Translating Faith-Based Lessons into Secular Philanthropy

Even for organizations that strive to remain neutral and nonsectarian, there is much to learn from the strategies faith-based campaigns have refined. The goal is not to adopt religious practices, but to adapt underlying principles like mission-centered messaging, communal participation, and values-driven appeals into a secular context. When applied thoughtfully, these lessons help any nonprofit strengthen its case for support, inspire deeper donor engagement, and leave communities more united and resilient long after a campaign ends.

Conclusion

Faith-based fundraising campaigns demonstrate that giving is most effective when rooted in meaningful mission and community. It goes beyond financial strategy. Cultivating trust through transparency and sharing your organization’s mission helps inspire your community to give — and to give sacrificially.

Even in a secular context, placing mission, leadership, and stewardship at the center of a fundraising effort will inspire strong support.

We value your insights! What stood out to you in this article? Join or start a conversation below.
  • Matt serves as the CEO of the Steier Group. He joined the firm in 2008, after working in the legal profession for more than 15 years. After spending seven years leading capital campaigns for faith-based organizations across the country, Matt joined the firm’s management team – first, as a project supervisor, then as President and most recently as CEO. Matt provides oversight for all the Steier Group’s campaigns and leads the firm’s client development efforts. Matt resides in Omaha, Nebraska, with his wife, Liz, and their three children.

    View all posts

Related Posts

Colored open hand illustration

Seeking Visionary Voices

Do you have:

  • A bold idea or unique insight?
  • A story of success—or hard-won lessons from failure?
  • Expert advice your peers need to hear?

Join other forward-thinkers shaping the future of philanthropy. Share your perspective, elevate the conversation, and let your voice be heard.

Contribute your wisdom today.

Related Posts

Calm workspace overlooking an autumn forest through a large window, symbolizing transparency, clarity, and strong nonprofit governance

How Zero-Staff Governance Built a $2M+ Endowment

Small nonprofits don’t need staff or scale to achieve big-institution results. The GOSUMEC Foundation USA built a $2M+ endowment with 95% donor retention and zero campaigns by combining identity-centered community design, disciplined governance, and radical transparency. Its ICCO™ model turns donors into co-owners, while the GIVE cycle converts gratitude and voice into recurring support. Governance—not overhead—became the infrastructure, proving trust is the ultimate operating system for small nonprofits.

Read More »
Close-up of a futuristic artificial intelligence hand glowing with red neural network lights, symbolizing AI power and digital transformation in the nonprofit sector

AI and Nonprofits: Poll Results

Nonprofits aren’t “exploring” AI—they’ve already outsourced half their workload to it, mostly without policies, guardrails, or governance. Our latest sector poll shows AI has crossed from experiment to infrastructure while leadership naps. Staff are using it to survive; organizations pretend it’s optional. This is the wake-up call: AI won’t level the field—it will widen it. The competent will soar, and the careless will get exposed.

Read More »
Colorful brain illustration representing dopamine, oxytocin, and the neuroscience of generosity with neural connections radiating outward.

Neuro-Philanthropy: From Dopamine to Oxytocin

Philanthropy has mastered urgency — the dopamine-fueled rush of campaigns and instant action — but sustainable giving requires something deeper: relationship. Neuroscience shows that while dopamine sparks generosity, oxytocin sustains it by building trust, belonging, and identity. When nonprofits move beyond transactions and cultivate connection, donors shift from one-time givers to long-term partners — and ultimately to legacy supporters. The future of philanthropy lies not in louder appeals, but in nurturing relationships that endure and compound over time.

Read More »
Google-style search bars with the phrases “It’s All Here…” and “At Your Fingertips,” highlighting that information is easily accessible. Donor cultivation is critical. Fundraisers must understand money and how their donors think.

Ignorance Is Not a Fundraising Strategy

Do you know how wealthy donors think? Can you explain the gap between a millionaire and a billionaire? Have you checked LinkedIn before your last donor meeting? Do you track economic indicators shaping giving decisions? Most fundraisers can’t answer these questions—and that ignorance costs millions. Google is free. LinkedIn is free. Zillow is free. Donors don’t owe you their money. Show up prepared or leave empty-handed.

Read More »
>