Why Nonprofits Must Think and Act Like Businesses

Tree split in half right side with leaves looking forward to future.
Reading Time: 3 minutes

In today’s fast-changing world, nonprofits face bigger challenges than ever before. To survive and thrive, these organizations need to think and act more like businesses. That doesn’t mean losing their sense of purpose or abandoning their mission—it means strengthening their impact by being smarter and more strategic. In short: adopting a business mindset. As Viken Mikaelian, CEO of PlannedGiving.com, often says, running a nonprofit isn’t an excuse to ignore business principles. It’s the key to long-term success.

Playing It Safe Won’t Cut It

Let’s face it—most people in the nonprofit world play it safe. It’s human nature. Since the beginning of time, we’ve been wired to avoid risks because that’s how we survive. But while this instinct may protect us from danger, it also holds us back. Success requires doing bold, unconventional things that often draw criticism. And nonprofits are not immune from this.

Here’s the hard truth: criticism is the cost of entry to success. Most people aren’t willing to pay it. Nonprofits tend to stick to what’s comfortable, but comfort rarely leads to greatness.

Another challenge is the widespread belief that showing up is enough. Many nonprofits embrace a “participation trophy” mentality, where effort is celebrated regardless of the outcome. But the world doesn’t reward potential—it rewards action. Results matter. This mindset keeps organizations stuck in mediocrity and leaves employees wondering why their hard work doesn’t pay off.

And what happens when things go wrong? Too often, nonprofit employees panic and hide. Mistakes and setbacks are inevitable, but no one ever became successful—or built a thriving nonprofit—by panicking. Success comes from resilience, not retreating when the going gets tough.

The Problem With “Free”

There’s also a belief in the nonprofit sector that many things should be free. People forget that someone has to pay for the salaries, tools, and resources needed to produce those “free” things. This mentality stems from a misunderstanding of how the world works and reflects a reluctance to engage with business realities. Without financial sustainability, no nonprofit can achieve its mission.

A Smarter Approach

If nonprofits want to succeed, they need to adopt a business mindset. Here’s how:

1. Take Risks and Embrace Criticism

Playing it safe isn’t enough. Nonprofits need to take calculated risks, whether it’s launching a new program, investing in technology, or trying something entirely different. Criticism will come—it’s proof that you’re making an impact.

2. Build a Strong Brand

Branding isn’t just for businesses. A strong brand establishes trust and authority, both of which are essential for fundraising. As Kevin L. Brown from Philanthropy.org explains, a clear and compelling brand inspires confidence and creates a foundation for everything a nonprofit does.

3. Treat Marketing as an Investment

Marketing isn’t an unnecessary expense—it’s one of the smartest investments a nonprofit can make. Digital campaigns, social media, and email outreach can help organizations connect with donors, tell their story, and increase their impact.

4. Reward Results, Not Just Participation

Celebrate achievements that drive meaningful outcomes. Focus on those who take initiative and produce results. Moving beyond a participation-based mindset to a business mindset not only motivates employees, but also sets a standard for excellence.

5. Build Resilience

Mistakes are part of the journey. When challenges arise, don’t panic—step up. Resilient teams that tackle problems head-on are the ones that grow and thrive.

6. Leverage Outside Talent

Sometimes, the best way to innovate is to bring in fresh perspectives. Hiring freelancers or contractors can provide specialized skills without increasing overhead. Mikaelian strongly recommends this approach to keep organizations competitive.

The Power of Planned Giving

One of the most underused tools in the nonprofit sector is planned giving. It’s a long-term strategy that provides stability and builds lasting relationships with donors. Yet, many nonprofits overlook it in favor of immediate fundraising goals. Viken Mikaelian is a passionate advocate for planned giving because it’s a game-changer for nonprofits.

Time to Step Up

Running a nonprofit like a business doesn’t mean abandoning your mission—it means amplifying your impact. Playing it safe, avoiding competition, or panicking when things go wrong won’t get you there. The world rewards bold action, not potential.

If nonprofits want to make a difference, they need to focus on what matters. Take action. Invest in growth. Embrace criticism. Adopt a business mindset. And most importantly, don’t be afraid to do the hard things that lead to real success.

The bottom line? You need to run your nonprofit like a business, because the organizations that adapt will not only survive—they’ll thrive.

We value your insights! What stood out to you in this article? Join or start a conversation below.
  • Joe is President of Garecht Fundraising Associates and has over 25 years of experience in fundraising and nonprofit management. He has led a $20M+ organization as Executive Director, served as VP of Development for a major educational nonprofit, and directed development at a large social service agency. Joe has consulted with hundreds of organizations, authored several books, including How to Raise More Money for Any Non-Profit and The Non-Profit Fundraising Formula, and works with clients nationwide and internationally.

    View all posts

Related Posts

Colored open hand illustration

Seeking Visionary Voices

Do you have:

  • A bold idea or unique insight?
  • A story of success—or hard-won lessons from failure?
  • Expert advice your peers need to hear?

Join other forward-thinkers shaping the future of philanthropy. Share your perspective, elevate the conversation, and let your voice be heard.

Contribute your wisdom today.

Related Posts

Wall Street Journal Clipping: Many Colleges Fail in Teaching How to Think

Many Colleges Fail in Teaching How to Think — And Donors Are Catching On

In 2017, the Wall Street Journal warned: “Many Colleges Fail in Teaching How to Think.” Eight years later, was it prophecy? Alumni giving is down. Public confidence has collapsed. Colleges are closing almost weekly. Donors now ask: Am I funding thinkers—or just diplomas? Real education, or expensive amenities? If students leave no better at reasoning than when they arrived, why should anyone keep writing checks? The warning was clear. The collapse was inevitable.

Read More »
Surreal desert landscape shaped like a human eye, symbolizing the illusion behind inflated legacy gift lists and the need for clearer vision

The $117 Million Mirage: Why Most Legacy Gift Lists Are Illusions

A nonprofit celebrated 1,270 bequest commitments worth $117 million. Reality check: filtering for actual prospects yielded 55 names. Calling those 55? They reached five people—none remembered making any commitment. The culprit: organizations spending $8,000-$20,000 annually on digital tools, expecting software to cultivate donor relationships. When results disappoint, staff move on, leaving nonprofits with the cleanup. The lesson: five genuine legacy phone calls will always outperform 1,270 fictional commitments. You can’t build relationships with shiny website objects.

Read More »
Depiction of Harvard University

Would You Donate to Harvard?

Harvard: citadel of brilliance or fortress of privilege? For decades, liberals slammed it as an elitist gatekeeper—legacy admissions, donor perks, and wealth dressed up as meritocracy. Now, conservatives aim to gut its funding, branding it a woke factory. Different flags, same battlefield. Reform or revenge—the motives have shifted, but Harvard remains rich, elite, and untouchable. The question isn’t whether it deserves criticism. It’s whether you’d bankroll an empire of inherited advantage… or gamble on the promise of change.

Read More »
>