Have We Been Here Before?

Finger poised over a glowing red panic button—symbolizing the urgent, high-stakes decisions nonprofits face in uncertain times.
Reading Time: 4 minutes

Last week, I met with the board of a historic property. They had spent years preparing for a campaign to create a new education center and enlarge their endowment. Each step was carefully taken: strategic planning, building the capacity of fundraising infrastructure, strengthening governance, engaging stakeholders. Yet they were anxious. Their careful preparation set the stage for dramatic growth, just as social and economic disruptions appeared. Should they proceed in the face of such headwinds?

It seems that every few years, there’s a shock to charitable giving. 

Five years ago, COVID shut down our offices, classrooms, and arts venues. Fundraising teams quickly pivoted to vigorous donor engagement, which they could implement because their time wasn’t devoted to in-person administration and meetings. American donors responded with extraordinary generosity. In the wake of obvious needs and limited opportunities for discretionary spending, 2020 and 2021 set new highs for charitable giving.

In years past, philanthropy has withstood a variety of disruptions. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 diminished charitable incentives and curtailed the rate of growth in giving (according to studies by Notre Dame and Indiana Universities), yet giving still eclipsed half a billion dollars by 2021. The “Great Recession” (2007-2009) saw a brief decline in charitable contributions, but the drop (2%) was slight compared to the declines in the equity markets (48%) and other economic indicators. The double-whammy of the “dot-com crash” and attacks of 9/11 taught us that donors will remain generous, as long as the causes they support continue to ask. Since 1967, giving has grown at an average rate of 6% (in current dollars) and suffered declines—often slight—only six times. 

Is 2025 any different?

Since January 20, many in the nonprofit sector, including their funders and beneficiaries, have grown increasingly anxious. Executive orders imperil programs and endowments while threats to funding put some organizations’ very existence at risk. Polarization has resulted in a messaging minefield. Threatened tariffs and other economic shocks have spooked investors as the equity markets stagger. 

The past has shown us that anxiety is the enemy of philanthropy.   

When markets falter or social shocks occur, donors are tempted to sit on the sidelines as the storms pass. That’s bad news for nonprofit organizations that depend on contributed revenue. Typically, it has taken six to 18 months for donor confidence to rebound after an economic or political disruption. While the optimist may calculate that a routine giving environment will emerge yet this year, and a pessimist abandons hope and delays action, a realist will take steps now to resist declines—and even thrive. How?

The word ‘ANXIETY’ filled with faces showing fear and worry—capturing the emotional state of nonprofit leaders facing uncertainty.

1. Project Resilience

Your organization has weathered past storms and emerged stronger. The current environment may necessitate decisions that will be painful for your co-workers or clients. Nevertheless, your mission will persist. Continue to center your mission and its impact in all messages and actions. You may need to use different words—to resonate with stakeholders and avoid conflict—but you can still do the work. Find additional guidance on specific messaging tactics in, “Fundraising in the Age of Disruption: Communicating with Conviction and Courage,” written by our communications team.

2. Sustain Relationships

“Change isn’t built on hostility,” Jennifer Sirangelo, President and CEO at Points of Light, observed recently “…step away from the internet and connect with people in real life.” Unlike the COVID days when calendars were suddenly wide open and outreach was a welcome task, you may feel that additional outreach is just one more burden on your too-long “to do” list. Instead of adding tasks, consider all of the ways you already engage stakeholders, and use those opportunities to provide reassurance and restate your mission. Be sure to have an inventory of stories that will illustrate your ongoing impact in a way that will resonate

3. Don’t react. Respond.

When news cycles are filled with inaccuracies or opposing viewpoints that create misperceptions, it is tempting to urgently declare what you are not. While refuting misinformation might be satisfying, it probably isn’t strategic. Instead, focus all messages and actions on the best of what you are.

4. Adopt donor-centric solicitation strategies.

This might not be the time to ask a donor for a five-year pledge to fulfill a $1 million gift to realize her dream of an endowed scholarship. Instead, consider asking the donor to give $200,000 now, and promise to revisit the situation in a year when the forecast will (hopefully) be clearer. For other examples of donor-centric giving strategies, consider some of the methods we discussed in, “14 Tactics for an Uncertain 2025.”

In many ways, the current environment does feel different than those earlier disruptions. We can still apply the lessons learned in the past, and gain new insights to make our causes even more resilient for the future.

What did I suggest to the leaders of the historic site? You can probably guess by now:

Don’t make pre-emptive decisions for your donors or your community. You may find that the going is tough in the beginning. You may find that donors need to express their anxiety before they’re willing to learn about your aspirations. Every campaign experiences a variety of economic, social, and political situations over multiple years of fundraising. By starting now, you’ll be poised to soar when conditions improve and your peers—who lacked confidence—are just getting started. Stay the course.

We value your insights! What stood out to you in this article? Join or start a conversation below.

  • Laura has over 40 years of experience in fundraising and philanthropy. Her media and communications background informed her storytelling ability for hundreds of nonprofit clients, with fundraising skills sharpened during The Ohio State University's first billion-dollar campaign. In 2000, Laura founded Benefactor Group, serving nonprofits for 25 years by helping organizations fuel their cause with powerful fundraising, people, and systems. A frequent speaker and published thought leader, Laura's insights have appeared in Advancing Philanthropy, Nonprofit Quarterly, Forbes.com, The New York Times, and the Chronicle of Philanthropy. She authored The Endowment Handbook (Wiley, 2024) and has served with the Association of Fundraising Professionals, Giving Institute, and Giving USA Foundation, where she was board chair from 2020-2022.

    View all posts

Related Posts

Colored open hand illustration

Seeking Visionary Voices

Do you have:

  • A bold idea or unique insight?
  • A story of success—or hard-won lessons from failure?
  • Expert advice your peers need to hear?

Join other forward-thinkers shaping the future of philanthropy. Share your perspective, elevate the conversation, and let your voice be heard.

Contribute your wisdom today.

Related Posts

Guests mingle at an elegant nonprofit gala under warm string lights, embodying a spirit of connection and intentional hospitality. When nonprofit events lead with hospitality, we move from transactions to transformations; build relationships; and embrace missions.

Unreasonable Hospitality: Transforming Nonprofit Events from Fundraisers to Movement Builders

When donors begin their estate planning journey on your website, they stay within your secure, branded ecosystem. No redirects to third-party vendors. No loss of control over sensitive donor data. We own PlannedGiving.org—the domain trusted by donors, attorneys, and financial advisors nationwide. Your custom URL (yourname.plannedgiving.org) keeps your brand front and center, unlike typical vendor URLs that bury your identity (vendor.com/yourname). Every detail matters when building donor trust and protecting your brand equity throughout the planned giving process.RetryClaude can make mistakes. Please double-check responses.

Read More »
Frustrated fundraiser overwhelmed at desk with coffee cup, laptop, and donor charts—reflecting burnout and job dissatisfaction in the nonprofit sector.

Why do Nonprofits Struggle to Retain Fundraising Staff?

Fundraisers often leave nonprofits not because of money, but due to burnout and misalignment between mission and daily operations. Passion for the cause can be overshadowed by relentless financial pressures, lack of authenticity from leadership, and inconsistent internal messaging. When leadership fails to communicate transparently or support staff meaningfully, trust erodes. Organizations that retain fundraising talent foster mission-driven cultures, prioritize authentic leadership, and ensure that every team member feels genuinely connected to the work and valued in their role.

Read More »
A cartoon image of three yellow figures standing on three green arrows pointing to a bullseye target. It illustrates the concept that financial advisors should form relationships with nonprofits.

Financial Advisors Should Befriend Nonprofits — Before Their Clients Do

As $84 trillion transfers from Baby Boomers to younger generations, financial advisors risk losing both clients and assets to charitable giving—unless they act strategically. When donors establish charitable vehicles without advisor involvement, that wealth often moves permanently outside the advisor’s purview to competitors like Fidelity Charitable or nonprofit-referred planners. The solution? Build intentional relationships with nonprofits before clients do. This triangular alliance—advisor + donor + nonprofit—creates stronger outcomes for everyone while protecting assets under management and positioning advisors as indispensable partners in legacy planning conversations that matter most.

Read More »
Financial advisor reading messages on smartphone disappointed at the news. Why should advisors embrace philanthropy? Because the Great Wealth Transfer is already happening.

Why Advisors Are About to Lose Their Best Clients

Advisors: You’re About to Get Fired: An $84 trillion wealth transfer is coming—and your name’s not on the guest list. The moment your client dies, retires, or checks into assisted living, their kids will hand everything to a friend from college or church. Unless you’ve built credibility with the next generation—and brought philanthropy into the conversation—you’re toast. Legacy is the new currency. Master it, or watch your book bleed out while someone else becomes the family’s trusted advisor.

Read More »
>