Donors Want a Story to Remember, Not a Fact to Memorize

Cameraman preparing a video recording for a story
Reading Time: < 1 minute

You don’t need more data in your fundraising.

Instead, go get:

Why?

In an aid-effectiveness study — published in the European Journal of Development Research — thousands of German donors said nonprofit testimonials — stories — resonate more than data.

And 56% of social media users who donate online said compelling storytelling makes them give most, according to Nonprofit Tech for Good. Stories were the number one motivation, while data wasn’t on the list.

Don’t get me wrong.

Investing in measurement is simply the right thing to do for impact accountability. So narrative + numbers is the ultimate fundraising combo. 

But “people forget facts; they never forget a good story,” says fundraising expert Claire Axelrad, J.D., CFRE.

Numbers tell. Stories sell.

And good storytelling is the probably the most powerful tool your nonprofit can utilize. 

The Daily Bonus

Donors initially give based on emotional signals — like your brand, storytelling, and communication skills — but then justify that gift with logic.

(Even if they don’t admit it.)

In fact, Harvard Business Review says 95% of our purchase decisions occur unconsciously. And their research found that our conscious mind will later make up reasons to validate our unconscious choices.

“Advances in neuroscience have helped us to understand that the brain processes meaning before detail,” says fundraising firm For Impact.

We value your insights! What stood out to you in this article? Join or start a conversation below.

    • Do you feel unseen, unheard, and underfunded? To get funding, you need to be fundable & findable. It’s your brand — not fundraising alone — that attracts the money. So stop chasing donations and build your brand first, funding second.

      View all posts

    Related Posts

    Colored open hand illustration

    Seeking Visionary Voices

    Do you have:

    • A bold idea or unique insight?
    • A story of success—or hard-won lessons from failure?
    • Expert advice your peers need to hear?

    Join other forward-thinkers shaping the future of philanthropy. Share your perspective, elevate the conversation, and let your voice be heard.

    Contribute your wisdom today.

    Related Posts

    Nonprofit board members sitting in a conference room - watercolor rendering

    Nonprofit Boards Should Include Young People

    It’s time we stop thinking of young people as future leaders and start recognizing them as current ones. Boards are not clubs for years served but strategic bodies for stewarding the mission. Readiness isn’t about age—it’s about perspective, commitment, and passion. Including younger voices isn’t symbolic—it’s strategic. They bring energy, authenticity, and digital fluency. If your board makes decisions about youth, equity, or tech, their presence isn’t optional—it’s essential. Empower them, don’t just appoint them.

    Read More »
    Concerned fundraising professional reading tax reform updates, reflecting nonprofit sector’s uncertainty after the One Big Beautiful Bill Act passed.

    New Law, Same Panic

    On July 4th, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBB) became law—prompting predictable panic in the nonprofit sector. Critics decried lower top-tier deductions and a new AGI floor. But pause. OBBB didn’t undercut charitable giving—it strengthened it. By making key reforms permanent, it created clarity: a 60% AGI limit for cash gifts, a new deduction for non-itemizers, and preserved estate exemptions. Just as important, it solidified long-term economic stability—an essential foundation for future generosity. This wasn’t a loss; it was a safeguard. The smart fundraiser sees the opportunity, not the noise. It’s time to stop reacting—and start leading.

    Read More »
    Guests mingle at an elegant nonprofit gala under warm string lights, embodying a spirit of connection and intentional hospitality. When nonprofit events lead with hospitality, we move from transactions to transformations; build relationships; and embrace missions.

    Unreasonable Hospitality: Transforming Nonprofit Events from Fundraisers to Movement Builders

    When donors begin their estate planning journey on your website, they stay within your secure, branded ecosystem. No redirects to third-party vendors. No loss of control over sensitive donor data. We own PlannedGiving.org—the domain trusted by donors, attorneys, and financial advisors nationwide. Your custom URL (yourname.plannedgiving.org) keeps your brand front and center, unlike typical vendor URLs that bury your identity (vendor.com/yourname). Every detail matters when building donor trust and protecting your brand equity throughout the planned giving process.RetryClaude can make mistakes. Please double-check responses.

    Read More »
    Illustration of a crouching nonprofit leader under a lightning-cracking storm cloud, symbolizing organizational fragility and looming Black Swan crises.

    Built to Break: How Nonprofit Culture Creates Its Own Crises

    Many nonprofits operate like unsuspecting turkeys, assuming past stability guarantees future safety. Built on feel-good events, crisis-driven appeals and compliance-focused boards, they remain fragile when unpredictable Black Swans—economic shocks, political upheavals, shifting donor sentiment—strike. Reactivity replaces strategy, visibility trumps resilience, and metrics reward vulnerability over strength. True antifragility requires cultivating long-term donor relationships, endowments, dissent-welcome hiring, mission-anchored vision, and durable structures that absorb disruption and emerge stronger, turning inevitable crises into growth catalysts for mission-driven impact ahead.

    Read More »
    >