Donors Want a Story to Remember, Not a Fact to Memorize

Cameraman preparing a video recording for a story
Reading Time: < 1 minute

You don’t need more data in your fundraising.

Instead, go get:

Why?

In an aid-effectiveness study — published in the European Journal of Development Research — thousands of German donors said nonprofit testimonials — stories — resonate more than data.

And 56% of social media users who donate online said compelling storytelling makes them give most, according to Nonprofit Tech for Good. Stories were the number one motivation, while data wasn’t on the list.

Don’t get me wrong.

Investing in measurement is simply the right thing to do for impact accountability. So narrative + numbers is the ultimate fundraising combo. 

But “people forget facts; they never forget a good story,” says fundraising expert Claire Axelrad, J.D., CFRE.

Numbers tell. Stories sell.

And good storytelling is the probably the most powerful tool your nonprofit can utilize. 

The Daily Bonus

Donors initially give based on emotional signals — like your brand, storytelling, and communication skills — but then justify that gift with logic.

(Even if they don’t admit it.)

In fact, Harvard Business Review says 95% of our purchase decisions occur unconsciously. And their research found that our conscious mind will later make up reasons to validate our unconscious choices.

“Advances in neuroscience have helped us to understand that the brain processes meaning before detail,” says fundraising firm For Impact.

We value your insights! What stood out to you in this article? Join or start a conversation below.

One Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Do you feel unseen, unheard, and underfunded? To get funding, you need to be fundable & findable. It’s your brand — not fundraising alone — that attracts the money. So stop chasing donations and build your brand first, funding second.

    View all posts

Related Posts

Colored open hand illustration

Seeking Visionary Voices

Do you have:

  • A bold idea or unique insight?
  • A story of success—or hard-won lessons from failure?
  • Expert advice your peers need to hear?

Join other forward-thinkers shaping the future of philanthropy. Share your perspective, elevate the conversation, and let your voice be heard.

Contribute your wisdom today.

Related Posts

Cracked pink piggy bank with coins spilling out, symbolizing the fractured state of donor participation in American philanthropy

The Participation Crisis Isn’t About Money — It’s About Meaning

Philanthropy isn’t dying—it’s consolidating. Americans gave $592B last year, but participating households plummeted from 65% to 45%. The culprit isn’t donor apathy; it’s nonprofit incompetence. Fragmented systems, spreadsheet chaos, and burnout have severed the human connection that sustains giving. Dr. Sanjay Bindra’s GOSUMEC Foundation proves the fix: zero staff, $10K tech stack, 90% recurring donor retention. Stop chasing dopamine hits. Build oxytocin ecosystems. Belonging beats begging.

Read More »
A lemon beside a mirror reflecting a lemon half, symbolizing a mismatch between appearance and reality.

Digital Dissonance: When Your Website Contradicts Your Mission

Nonprofits often build websites that look impressive but feel hollow. In chasing “professional,” they erase their own voice, personality, and lived reality. The result is digital dissonance—a subtle but powerful mismatch between who an organization actually is and how it presents itself online. Visitors feel it instantly. They don’t complain. They just leave, unconvinced and unlikely to return.

Read More »
Stone stairway ascending through clouds toward bright sunlight

Mission-Driven Giving at Work: What Faith-Based Campaigns Can Teach the Philanthropy Sector

Faith-based fundraising offers powerful lessons for the broader philanthropy sector. By anchoring giving in mission, community, and shared values, these campaigns inspire deeper donor commitment. Their focus on storytelling, transparency, leadership participation, and consistent engagement creates a culture of generosity. As Millennials and Gen Z prioritize mission-driven giving, nonprofits that adopt these principles can strengthen donor relationships, increase participation, and build more resilient, purpose-driven communities.

Read More »
Calm workspace overlooking an autumn forest through a large window, symbolizing transparency, clarity, and strong nonprofit governance

How Zero-Staff Governance Built a $2M+ Endowment

Small nonprofits don’t need staff or scale to achieve big-institution results. The GOSUMEC Foundation USA built a $2M+ endowment with 95% donor retention and zero campaigns by combining identity-centered community design, disciplined governance, and radical transparency. Its ICCO™ model turns donors into co-owners, while the GIVE cycle converts gratitude and voice into recurring support. Governance—not overhead—became the infrastructure, proving trust is the ultimate operating system for small nonprofits.

Read More »
>